Solving for Y with Cups and Kisses!

My students beautifully tackled two step equations with ease, showing all of their steps along the way and solving to perfection!  So, when it was time to graph, I decided that we would spend a day solving for y before learning all of the different forms of the equation of a line.  Sometimes as a teacher, you assume a new concept will be easy for your students.  However, my students are treading through the new waters of Algebra, and what seems obvious to me is not always obvious to them.  After I spent hours making a fun “Solving for Y” Jeopardy game so that would could spend an hour solving equations for y with glee, we instead spent an hour of misery.  The kids were tortured by the problems that they thought were “way too hard” simply because they did not understand what they were supposed to be doing.

My mistake was that I assumed since they could solve for x in two-step equations so beautifully, that throwing a y in there would be no problem.  What I missed was that unlike students I teach in high school, these students had never solved equations with two variables before and simply did not know what to do with them.  Can you add them, subtract them, put them together?  Solve for y?  THAT is not an answer!  We are used to seeing x=12 as an answer, not y = 2x – 5.  Ohhhh….. Finally my light bulb went on.

I felt so bad.  I wasted a day of learning (for them, as I had learned a GREAT deal).  I was desperate for them to see how easy it was to solve for y, and let them get lots of practice at solving for y at the same time.  But, I had already lost a day, and some of their trust.  They did NOT like this “solving for y”.  I had messed up.

So, what do you do when you mess up and want to make it right?  Well, give them candy of course!  ; )  Thanks to an amazing brainstorming session with the wonderful, brilliant teachers on Twitter a new plan was devised.  We would solve for y in the style of “Hands On Equations” with small Solo cups, Hershey kisses, and integer counters.

I used two colors of Kisses (one for +x, one for -x), solo cups for y (sorry, no -y’s), yellow and red integer circles for the numbers, and my “Hands On Equations” equation mats.  I made a worksheet (at end) and modeled the equations with my new best friend, Elmo.  I had them model EACH equation, and write exactly what they modeled (in equation solving form) on their worksheet.  THEN, we moved on to solving without cups and kisses.

**  The BEST part of this activity was by far the cups!  **

When I had 3y = 6x + 3, I asked them, if 3 cups equals 6 Kisses and 3 chips, then how much does EACH cup (or y) have?  By using cups they could actually put 2 Kisses and 1 chip in each cup.  An unexpected plus of the cups was that the students did not once forget to divide BOTH the coefficient of x AND the constant by the coefficient of y!

Solving for Y with Kisses and Cups

Another highlight of the activity was the last problem.  It came down to 4y = x + 4.  I was so excited to see the students realize that each cup got 1/4 of a Kiss!  They discovered that they had to split the Kiss into fourths to put an equal amount of Kiss into each cup.  So, the answer was y = (1/4)x + 1.   My HS students in the past have always had trouble extracting the slope when they come up with y = x/4 +1.  I am really hoping Kisses help them greatly with this!  We will see this week as we delve into finding slope!  : )

My favorite part of the whole day was hearing kids say, “Wow, this is so easy!”.  Their favorite part was eating the 6 Kisses I allotted per student at the end of class.

Solving For Y with Cups and Kisses Activity Sheet

12 thoughts on “Solving for Y with Cups and Kisses!

  1. I am doing this tomorrow with my 6th grade so of course needed to re-read my blog to remember what I did last year. 🙂

    I am going to try the upside down cups! Also, I bought the Hershey’s drops this time instead of kisses. They come in two colors – and it is still chocolate so WIN-WIN!

  2. How did you communicate that when you move the x (kisses) to the other side, that it was subtracted from BOTH sides? I did a similar activity and some of my students think you subtract from one side and add to the other. I understand where they are coming from, but I can’t figure out how to fix it.

    • We don’t solve for y until 7th grade. In 6th I teach equation solving using a balance scale and inverse operations. They know that to keep the equation balanced they must do the same thing to both sides. In 7th, introducing two variables is what confuses them so that is why I used two different items, cups and kisses. I had to do balance scales first though so they knew what was going on. I hope this helped. 🙂

  3. Pingback: A Day in the Life… | Ms Moore Math

  4. Pingback: Solving for y and Introduce b | When Math Happens

  5. Pingback: My All Time Favorite Middle School Math Lessons | I Speak Math

  6. Pingback: Solve for y – Make Math Not Suck

  7. Hi! Box had a little trouble downloading the file. This looks like an amazing activity-the blog over at MathMathNotSuck highly raved about this activity. Would you perhaps mind emailing me a copy of the document “solving for y with kisses” when you get a chance?
    Thank you!

Leave a Reply to Pam Wilson Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s